Throwing Make-Up Away *waah*

So I think this is something that most people don't do, but they're suppose to. After a certain amount of time, depending on the make-up, you're suppose to trash them after 6-12 months. Well, I have a really hard time doing that. It's near impossible to use up a whole thing of make-up in that time period. 

Sad to say, with cream shadows, you have to because they get hard and nasty. I opened my Benefit Creaseless Cream Shadow today and my "Get Figgy" and " Skinny Jeans" were all dried up! I didn't even really get to use them that much. 

Am I the only one with attachment issues to my make-up?!?

You see how the bottom one is all shrunken around the sides? The top one is my newer one.